Background on Saudi/Rohingya Issues
January 2021
by the Editor of
Rohingya Crisis News

NOTE: THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION MAY BE IN ERROR.
THERE IS MUCH DISAGREEMENT AMONG SOURCES
AS TO THE EXACT FACTS IN THIS COMPLEX ISSUE.


Starting in the late 1970s, Saudi Arabia accepted tens of thousands of Rohingya refugees, who were fleeing persecution in Myanmar, and granted them residency in the Middle-Eastern desert kingdom. More came in subsequent years, and those already in the Kingdom began to have children.

By 2019, according to at least one source, an estimated 300,000 Rohingya were living in Saudi Arabia.

[NOTE: Saudi Arabia, like most of the oil-wealthy Gulf Arab states, has been notorious for importing poor foreigners to work as little more than slave-labor to Saudi enterprises (especially oil industry), or slave-like servants to the Saudi upper-class and upper-middle class -- then discarding and deporting them when they are no longer very useful (due to age, disability or rebellion, for instance, or due to downturns in global oil demand).]

Some of the Rohingya in Saudi Arabia gave birth, and raised generations of Rohingya children as Arab-speaking Saudi residents, though Saudi Arabia denied Saudi citizenship to those Rohingya.

PASSPORT PROBLEMS:

Some Rohingya acquired Bangladeshi passports. Some of the passports came from authorities in Bangladesh, others from Bangladeshi consulates in Saudi Arabia and elsewhere -- passports implying that the Rohingya were citizens of Bangladesh. The passports -- at least initially -- legitimized the Rohingya's travel and presence in Saudi Arabia.

The fact that Bangladesh has given passports to some of the Saudi Rohingya -- and thus implied they are Bangladeshi citizens -- arguably helps bolster Myanmar's claim that ALL Rohingya should actually be Bangladeshi citizens, rather than citizens of Myanmar.

This has created a problem for Bangladesh, in their repatriation negotiations with Myanmar (who insists that ALL Rohingya are actually "Bengalis" -- implicitly from Bangladesh -- and should live in Bangladesh).

Bangladesh now claims that those Bangladeshi passports, held by some Saudi-Rohingya, were fake or illegitimate -- and acquired through bribery, deceit, or other corrupt and illegal methods.

SAUDI  PUSH-BACK:

Starting in 2011, Saudi Arabia began resisting the influx of Rohingya refugees, and began interning them in detention camps.

Currently, about 500 to 1,000 are interned in a detention camp in Jeddah. In April 2019, about 650 of the men there protested by going on a hunger strike. Saudi Arabia has begun efforts to return them to Myanmar, or at least to Bangladesh.

The Bangladeshi passports held by some of the Rohingya have legitimized Saudi Arabia's deportation of them to Bangladesh (even though, actually, they are from Myanmar).

However, various human-rights groups and Rohingya advocates, have complained that the Saudi Rohingya are arrested upon landing in Bangladesh. The organizations, along with the United Nations human-rights official on the Myanmar-Rohingya issue (Yanghee Lee), have urged Saudi officials to just let their Rohingya refugees -- stateless people with no official "home country" -- to continue to live in Saudi Arabia. Bangladesh wants that, too.

EXPIRED PASSPORTS - FRESH PROBLEM:

At present, some of the passports, held by some of the Rohingya in Saudi Arabia, have expired -- and cannot be used to legitimize sending the Rohingya to Bangaldesh. So Saudi Arabia, in early 2021, has urged Bangladesh to supply current passports to replace those that have expired.

Bangladesh does not want to, because fresh passports will enable Saudi Arabia to start sending their Rohingya -- possibly tens of thousands of them -- to Bangladesh. But Bangladesh, a poor and desperate country, in need of foreign aid and development money, depends upon wealthy Saudi Arabia for significant amounts of that income.

Consequently, grudgingly, Bangladeshi Foreign Minister AK Abdul Momen, in late-2020 / early-2021, has assured the Saudi's that those Rohingya who had Bangladeshi passports will be provided with fresh, current ones.

BAD TIMING:

Unfortunately for Bangladesh, this fuss comes just as they are sitting down with Myanmar and China -- to try to hammer out a deal to return the Rohingya in Bangladesh back to Myanmar.

Myanmar, which doesn't want its Rohingya back, is expected to use the Bangladeshi passports -- and the deportation of Rohingyas from Saudi-Arabia to Bangladesh -- as "proof" that the Rohingya should actually be viewed as citizens of Bangladesh, and should stay there, rather than return to Myanmar.


For more detailed and direct information on the Rohingya issues with Saudi Arabia, see the following listed links to relevant article abstracts here in the Rohingya Crisis News.

After clicking on any link below, there will be a slight delay, while the system loads the entire RCN page for that year, then jumps to the listing and abstract for that specific article.


  • 06 Jan. 2019
    several articles,
    including:
    "Saudi Arabia continues to deport scores of Rohingya to Bangladesh"

    - Middle East Eye
  • 21 Jan. 2019
    Saudi Arabia to deport
    250 Rohingya to Bangladesh:
    ~ Activist group.

    - Al Jazeera (Arab news, Qatar)
    Saudi Arabia is home to almost 300,000 Rohingya, according to Nay San Lwin, campaign coordinator for the Free Rohingya Coalition, who urged authorities to stop the deportations, adding that the men faced imprisonment in Bangladesh upon their arrival.
  • 26 Jan. 2019
    Myanmar Failing to Create Conditions
    Needed for Rohingya Return
    ~ UN

    - The Irrawaddy (Myanmar)
    United Nations special rapporteur on the human rights situation in Myanmar, Yanghee Lee, ... expressed her annoyance over the deportation of Rohingya people from India and Saudi Arabia to Bangladesh -- adding that Delhi and Riyadh must ensure that the Rohingya people can live in safety and dignity within [Indian and Saudi Arabian] territories, until the refugees can return home.
  • 17 Apr. 2019
    Rohingya on hunger strike
    in Saudi detention.

    - Al Jazeera (Arab news network; Qatar)

    At least seven hospitalised after 650 Rohingya men refuse food at a detention centre in Jeddah, activists say. ...
    ...Since the start of this year, Saudi Arabia has forcibly deported dozens of Rohingya to Bangladesh - some of whom have been detained upon arrival at the Dhaka airport. ...


  • 26 Aug. 2019
    EDITORIAL:
    "Crimes in the Rohingya camps:
      Security needs to be beefed up."

        - Daily Star (Bangladesh)
      ...deteriorating law and order in the Rohingya refugee camps [in Bangladesh] ... Very recently, four Rohingya women were rescued from being trafficked to Saudi Arabia. ...
     
  • 15 Jan. 2021
    Rohingya:
    Why Bangladesh is in a diplomatic fix
    over Saudi repatriation.

    - Deutsch Welle (Germany)
      Riyadh has urged Bangladesh to take back some 54,000 Rohingya that are currently in Saudi Arabia. But agreeing to this would complicate Bangladesh's Rohingya repatriation talks with Myanmar. ...
    [NOTE: This article is one of the best explanations of the issues. ~RCN Editor]

  • 17 Jan. 2021
    Saudi envoy:
    Rohingyas with Bangladeshi passports
    considered Bangladeshis.

    ‘They’re not Bangladeshi citizens who are from Myanmar, they’re Myanmar citizens,’ [replies Bangladesh's] Home Minister Asaduzzaman Khan.
        - UNB / Dhaka Tribune (Bangladesh)
        - UNB / Daily Star (Bangladesh) )
      [NOTE: While unclear, these articles appear to indicate that the Saudi government is attempting to get Bangladesh to renew passports for 55,000 Rohingya, living in Saudi Arabia, who entered with Bangladeshi passports.
      Some of Saudi Arabia's Rohingya with current Bangladeshi passports have been deported to Bangladesh, and apparently 55,000 more could be sent to Bangladesh, if that country accommodates the Saudis, who are among its major financiers.
      There appears to be some hesitation on this issue, by Bangladesh, and the issue appears entangled with Bangladesh's immediate negotiations to repatriate several hundred thousand Rohingya back to Myanmar, because the granting of Bangladesh passports to Saudi Rohingya implies that they are actually from Bangladesh -- a claim Myanmar has made about all of the Rohingya, in its effort to drive them out of Myanmar, and into Bangladesh.]

~RCN Editor


////////